| Taking the weather for granted is easy to do on a nice day. Sails are filled with a gentle wind, and the boat heels slightly as it slices through rippling water shimmering beneath a warm sun. On days like these it is hard to imagine that sailing can be a totally different experience when conditions turn rough. A parachute sea anchor is typically deployed off the bow. It will almost stop the boat, allowing only a very slow drift downwind. It is a passive device. It does not demand the continuous attention of the crew. During heavy weather, the sea anchor allows the captain and crew to deal with exhaustion and seasickness, to maintain adequate nourishment, to tend to the boat, and to maintain rational decision-making abilities. To enable a safe landfall, a sea anchor can hold a boat in a favorable position until a heavy fog clears or daylight arrives. It can keep a boat off a lee shore until engine repairs can be made or help arrives. It provides a stable boat from which it is easier to dive, fish, or check your navigation. Historically, a sea anchor was anything from a leather bucket to a cone-shaped canvas scoop used off the bow to hold the boat in a safe position when faced with heavy wind and waves. Later, commercial fishermen and then sailors began using military surplus parachutes as sea anchors for the same purpose, thereby coining the name parachute sea anchor. These large-diameter devices have evolved over the years and offer much more holding power than their cone-shaped cousins. A boat forced aft against an oversized canopy that is “fixed” in the water can present problems. In his book, Heavy Weather Tactics Using Sea Anchors and Drogues, Earl Hinz points out, “The powerful but irregular motion of the sea when resisted by a sea anchor can produce great strains on the sea anchor gear. The dynamic of loading will give all of the problems found in ground anchoring, such as overloading cleats and Samson posts, causing severe chafe on the rode, and occasionally burying the bow in green water.” Larger chutes tend to take up more storage space aboard, cost more, and are often more difficult to deploy and retrieve. Deploying the parachute sea anchor is only half of the procedure. Retrieving it successfully is the other half. A trip line can make the retrieval process easier. The next choice is whether to use a full or partial trip line. Full trip lines extend from the apex of the chute all the way back to the boat; partial trip lines run to retrieval floats. Another concern about using parachute sea anchors is whether they will always hold the bow of a boat upwind. This is a controversial matter. Left to its own devices with no drag device, a modern monohull will normally lie ahull, meaning beam to the wind. This is caused at least in part by the center of aerodynamic drag (force of the wind) being forward of the center of hydrodynamic drag (force of the water acting on the hull). This is particularly true if the boat is not carrying sail. The sea anchor must overcome this natural tendency and pull the bow into the wind. While a monohull’s “natural” tendency is to lie ahull, in most cases it is quite easy to get these boats to be fairly stable sailing dead downwind under bare poles. Drogues take advantage of this natural stability. There are both unitary and series drogues. A unitary drogue is deployed as a single drag device attached at the end of a length of rode. A series drogue utilizes smaller drag devices, such as cones, all of which are attached along a length of rode. Most drogues are unitary drogues, and most unitary drogues are intended to reduce a boat’s speed to a safe and manageable level while allowing for a fair amount of directional control by the helmsman. Keeping the boat below hull speed can prevent surfing down large wave fronts and punching the bow into the back of the next wave in the trough. These drogues are referred to as speed-limiting or low-drag drogues to contrast them with medium-drag drogues (like the Jordan Series Drogue which is designed to virtually stop the boat). These drogues require active participation from the crew, but allow the helmsman greater control and ease of steering. In situations where it is desirable to keep moving to reach shelter, or to maneuver to a more favorable part of the weather system, these devices are preferable. However, the same low drag that grants more steering control can also make the boat more vulnerable to capsizing, broaching, or pitchpoling in a “once-in-a-lifetime storm.” In addition, with a single drag device at the end of a long rode, the boat is more susceptible to large waves that approach from an angle. In order for a boat to get assistance from the drogue, it must position itself by swinging at the end of the long rode. The time it takes to do this can be crucial, and failure can result in a wave hitting the boat broadside. Series drogues were invented and developed by Donald Jordan. These drogues are deployed off the stern but, like the bow-deployed parachute sea anchor, they are intended to almost stop the boat. In this manner, the stern of the boat faces toward the wind and waves. The advantage of this is that the boat is much more stable pointing and sailing slowly downwind. There is less tendency to yaw because the mast and other high wind-drag items are downwind of the keel and rudder which are the high water-drag items. A properly sized series drogue will keep the boat speed down to 1 to 1 ½ knots in storm conditions, so it does not require the crew to steer. In this attitude if the boat is struck by a large breaking wave, which is the most dangerous threat to a boat in heavy weather, the boat will be briefly accelerated up to wave speed, and then as the wave passes it will be dragged back by the series drogue. Unlike the sea anchor, the series drogue is intended to control the loads on the rode, fittings, and attachment points by allowing the breaking wave to accelerate the boat. It is not intended to have enough drag to resist this large and rapidly developed force. It does have enough drag to quickly bring the boat speed back down after the breaking wave passes. It will prevent the boat from being thrown into the trough. Donald Jordan asserts that a breaking wave will not damage a boat by striking it but can damage it by throwing it into the trough. The Jordan Series Drogue typically is made up of more than 100 small fabric cones. These smaller drag devices are located all along the length of the rode. Therefore, if half the cones are inactive within the slack portion of a wave, the other half are still capable of maintaining a hold on the boat. Also, if a large wave is approaching from an angle off the stern, the drag devices closer to the boat, where the rode elasticity is low, will create a load much faster than if a unitary drogue were being towed at the end of a long rode. The drogue is weighted by chain at the end, which makes it function below the wave action and keeps a constant tension on the rode. Because of the way the Jordan Series Drogue works, the stern will be struck by breaking waves. This is a controversial aspect of the device. Critics assert that the transom, cabin trunk, and drop boards must be capable of taking the full impact of breaking waves and that the impact will be severe. Donald Jordan contends that experience with his drogues has proven that this is not a problem. In any case, the cockpit should be able to drain water quickly, and all drogue attachments should be well backed up to help spread the loads imposed upon the gear. In addition, it is not intended that the crew be in the cockpit when the drogue is in use. The speed will be kept too low to allow the boat to be steered, and the crew should go below. Deployment of any drogue generally takes place over the stern. The whole assembly should be carefully checked to ensure knots are properly tied, shackles are safety wired, the bitter end is attached to the boat, and the system is free of tangles with itself as well as parts of the boat and crew. When the boat is in the trough of a wave, its speed is at its minimum. This is the time to deploy the drogue. In the case of unitary drogues, a portion of the rode nearest the boat is deployed first. As the boat moves forward, the water will pull the rode along in a bight. More of the rode is paid out until the drogue itself is reached. The device, previously laid out and checked for tangles, is then released. The series drogue has a length of anchor chain at the end to keep it below the surface. This is dropped into the water, and the drag from the chain is allowed to pull the rest of the drogue overboard. The series drogue is intended to be permanently attached to a bridle on the transom and ready for deployment at any time. Unitary drogues can also use an adjustable bridle setup. The main rode is led off to one side of the transom and secured to a strong cleat or reinforced attachment point, preferably forward of the rudder post to improve steering. A snatch block with a pendant line tied to it is then snatched onto the main rode. The pendant line is run off the other side and led to a winch for adjustment. This system allows the crew to position the boat’s stern to oncoming waves, exposing, for example, only the quarter portion of a flat transom to the full impact of a breaking wave. Once you have made a decision to purchase a parachute sea anchor or drogue, take the time to research all available options. “Silver-bullet storm tactics” are hard to come by because of the variety found in weather conditions, boat designs, personal preferences, and crew capabilities. There are other tactics to employ in heavy weather, such as running under bare poles and heaving-to. Using a drag device requires prior planning since the equipment must be aboard. If it is to be effective it must be ready for deployment, and you must be comfortable using it. If you equip your boat with drag devices, practice deploying them in moderate conditions. Get familiar with the components. Make sure all crew members know the procedure and their responsibilities. Click | | The above articles are provided as a courtesy by some of the industry's top rated boating magazines. If you would like to subscribe to any back issue or just want to learn more about safety at sea, simply click on the magazine link following the article. |
| - New Sailboats
- Sailboats 21-30ft
- Sailboats 31-35ft
- Sailboats 36-40ft
- Sailboats Over 40ft
- Sailboats Under 21feet
- used_sailboats
- Apps and Computer Programs
- Communications
- Fishfinders
- Handheld Electronics
- Plotters MFDS Rradar
- Wind, Speed & Depth Instruments
- Anchoring Mooring
- Running Rigging
- Sails Canvas
- Standing Rigging
- Diesel Engines
- Off Grid Energy
- Cleaning Waxing
- DIY Projects
- Repair, Tools & Materials
- Spare Parts
- Tools & Gadgets
- Cabin Comfort
- Ventilation
- Footwear Apparel
- Foul Weather Gear
- Mailport & PS Advisor
- Inside Practical Sailor Blog
- Activate My Web Access
- Reset Password
- Customer Service
Pearson 37 and 37-2 Used Boat ReviewDIY Survey Checklist for Used-Boat BuyingValiant 40: Reshaping the Cruising HullBristol Channel Cutter 28: Circumnavigator’s ChoiceBest Crimpers and Strippers for Fixing Marine Electrical ConnectorsThinking Through a Solar Power InstallationHow Does the Gulf Stream Influence our Weather?Can You Run a Marine Air-Conditioner on Battery Power?Practical Sailor Classic: The Load on Your RodeAnchor Rodes for Smaller SailboatsGround Tackle Inspection TipsShoe Goo II Excels for Quick Sail RepairsSpring Season Engine Start-Up for Winterized EnginesSolutions for a Stinky Holding TankDiesel Performance AdditivesHidden Maintenance Problems: Part 3 – Gremlins in the ElectricsSeepage or Flooding? How To Keep Water Out of the BoatAlcohol Stoves— Swan Song or Rebirth?Living Aboard with an Alcohol StoveChoosing the Right Fuel for Your Alcohol StovePreparing Yourself for Solo SailingHow to Select Crew for a Passage or DeliveryPreparing A Boat to Sail SoloRe-sealing the Seams on Waterproof FabricsChafe Protection for Dock LinesWaxing and Polishing Your BoatReducing Engine Room NoiseTricks and Tips to Forming Do-it-yourself Rigging TerminalsMarine Toilet Maintenance Tips- Sails, Rigging & Deck Gear
- Safety & Seamanship
How Much Drag is in a Drogue?Ps compares popular boat-slowing devices.. Weve long been interested in drogues, devices specifically designed to be towed behind a boat to reduce speed and to produce directional stability in heavy weather. Our last major drogue test was in 2009, when noted marine writers and circumnavigators Evans Starzinger and Beth Leonard shared their storm tactics (see Heavy Weather Sailing Tactics” . Another relevant article, Sea Anchors and Drogues , compared a variety of drag devices. If you are interested in purchasing a drogue, we recommend reading the archive articles along with this report. This study was intentionally limited to drogues for small to medium size boats (those between 30 and 45 feet). These are the boats that are more likely to benefit from using a drogue. Smaller boats rarely encounter conditions requiring a drogue, and on bigger boats, the high loads associated with using a drogue become problematic. Weve also limited our discussion to gale conditions (sustained 47 knots with higher gusts). With modern forecasting, very few sailors will ever experience a storm of this intensity underway, and the cautious coastal sailor never should. There are sailing-resource books that address using drogues in more severe conditions, but since our key data was recorded in sustained winds of 35 knots with gusts to 47 knots, the topic was beyond the scope of this report. Photos by Drew Frye What We TestedOur tests focused on drogues, which should not be confused with sea anchors. Drogues are generally deployed from the stern in heavy weather to slow a boat down and to add directional stability to prevent a broach. Sea anchors are typically deployed from the bow and are designed to hold a boat nearly stationary; parachute-type sea anchors from Fiorentino and Para-Tech fall into this category. For more on sea anchors and their use, see Sea Anchor Match-up , in the Feb. 1, 2005 issue online. Drogues are divided into two classes, with no absolute dividing line. Medium-drag devices are intended to slow the boat significantly and to apply more than 2,000 pounds of restraining force in the event of a very steep or breaking wave. Depending on size, they generally limit vessel steering, allowing only a downwind or slight reaching course. Ace Sailmakers Jordan Series Drogue and the Ocean Safety Para Drogue (depending on vessel it is used with) fall into this category, although other drogues would qualify if they are oversized for the vessel. Our focus for this test was on low-drag devices intended for steering a boat in difficult downwind sailing conditions, reducing yawing, preventing surfing, reducing broach potential, and generally making the life of the autopilot or helmsman easier. These devices can also be used to provide some steering control for a boat that has a damaged rudder. Low-drag drogues can be further classified into several design groups, each with features intended to improve stability at greater speeds as compared to standard parachute drogues. The Jimmy Green Yacht Drogue is an elongated cone, providing some glide surface for the water. The Para Drogue is a slotted parachute, with openings intended to stabilize flow along the canopy. The net-like Galerider, made by Hathaway, Reiser & Raymond, is made using heavy-duty webbing. And finally, there are the ballutes-the Burke Marine Seabrake, Fiorentino Shark, and Para-Tech Delta Drogue. A hybrid between balloon and parachute (thus the portmanteau ballutes), they operate like devices used to slow high-speed air and land craft. We fabricated one-third-scale versions of the major drogue types. This allowed us to roughly confirm scale-up factors and observe drogue behavior at higher loads. Data from small-scale tests was not used in calculating loads that appear in the accompanying table. Except where noted, the table data is based on testing on the following products: The full-size Seabrake GP24L, Delta Drogue 72, Galerider 30, and Yacht Drogue 25 were tested multiple times in a wide range of sea conditions: The Ocean Safety Para Drogue was tested in flat water only. The Jordan Series Drogue (109 cones) was tested once in flat water to confirm drag data. Not tested: Fiorentino Small Shark and other sizes of all drogues. We also tested a few do-it-yourself options: a towed warp (half-inch line plus chain) and a towed milk crate. How We TestedAlthough every manufacturer makes recommendations regarding the drogue size for a given vessel, its not always clear under what conditions their guidance is appropriate, and each boat and captain will have different storm management tactics. Some sailors believe a boat should sail fairly unrestrained, while others believe in more aggressive efforts to reduce speed. Our test focused on relevant performance and design details that we could objectively compare, including the counteracting forces generated by each drogue, how each drogue behaved in the water, and how easy they were to deploy and recover. We quantified the drag force versus speed for various drogue types and sizes. To evaluate factors that we could not physically test, such as the effects of wave dynamics (acceleration, angular change, and oscillation), we turned to other studies and databases, creating an extremely comprehensive data set for analysis. Finally, testers examined each drogue for construction quality and strength. For more details on test procedures, see How We Tested on top right. ObservationsDrogue makers recommend slowing the boat to a few knots and slowly feeding out rode, but that might not always be possible. In order to test the construction of the full-size drogues, we set each at 7.5 to 9 knots of boat speed, and none resulted in undue force on cleats. Keep in mind, this is not the recommended procedure. The point is that all of the test drogues were constructed to withstand many times the strain they should actually develop in the water. Medium ScopeTesters found very few surprises when testing at medium scope (100 feet). This is much shorter than the 350 feet generally recommended for actual use, but for testing, we sought to determine how the drogues would behave in steep, breaking waves. In a storm with dangerous breaking waves, the angle of the rode to the water is greatly reduced by the steepness of a breaking wave face, and the most common failure of a drogue is for it to pull out of steep wave faces. All of the drogues produced drag forces roughly proportional to the square of the boat speed. When the speed doubles, as long as the drogue stays in the water, drag force quadruples. Steady-speed testing using a sailboat, of course, does not tell us about higher speeds, so we towed one-third-scale models with a tender at up to 10 knots; the behavior of the drogues and the drag versus speed relationship did not differ significantly. The ratio of drag to projected area was also consistent for each basic design. All of the drogues stayed near the surface at higher speeds, but none broke the surface significantly. In most cases, the amount of drag fluctuated greatly. Readings varied by 35 to 60 percent over a three- to five-second timespan when towed at 5 knots. The dramatic exception was the Galerider, which fluctuated only 10 to 20 percent. The difference is likely explained by a basic design difference; while most designs inflate into solid shapes, the Galerider strains the water through a webbing net. The warp also gave very smooth drag, presumably due to its small cross-section. All of the drogues rotated to some extent, but this varied with sea state and speed. None spun enough to impair function, even when testers removed the swivels. For systems that include a swivel, its important to use a good-quality swivel and to keep it in good repair. Testers only noted significant lateral movement with the Jimmy Green drogue. This yawing would likely increase chafe on the rode, where it is led through a chock. Presumably, it could also affect steering, as it was occasionally pronounced, as much as 8 degrees to the side. All other devices in the test tracked straight. Short ScopeWe expected larger differences between models at short scope (50 feet), but there was not a wide variation. The solid drogues (Delta Drogue, Seabrake, and Shark) create a bulge of water as they approach the surface under high load. In order for the drogue to emerge, the force must be sustained for several seconds to disperse this lump of water, and then the drogue will suddenly surface. The Galerider, on the other hand, functions by straining the water and is less affected by its proximity to the waters surface, smoothly emerging and re-engaging. The Jimmy Green drogue was more prone to skipping when it broke the surface, likely an indicator of how any cone design would behave if it were yanked from a wave face; all others smoothly re-engaged. Drogue drag is not directly related to model size, so be sure to look at drag data and not just size when selecting a drogue. Additionally, makers are not all on the same page when it comes to storm tactics. Some recommend relatively low drag so that the boat will still be pushed forward (and possibly retain steerage) as it absorbs some of the wave energy, while others believe in higher drag to deliver positive speed reduction. If you prefer a low-drag design (Galerider, for example) but would like more drag, you can consider going up a size. Some of the devices we tested included an attached weight, such as a mushroom anchor, to prevent the drogues surfacing. Conventional wisdom suggests that 10 to 30 feet of chain (length and weight will depend on drogue type and size) should be placed in front of the drogue to keep it submerged and to sink it nose-first in the lulls, preventing slack from forming in the rode between waves. Fiorentino, however, recommends adding the weight to the tail of its Shark via a dedicated pendant. Testers noted that attaching the chain to the tail made deployment easier. While the weight of the chain or mushroom anchor will help keep the drogue in the water, hydrodynamic forces around the drogue and in the waves are far more influential. Interestingly, Galerider does not address using chain, except on very short rodes when used for emergency steering; however, many users do add a chain leader, which they say improves performance. When budgeting for a new drogue, remember that the drogue itself is only about half of the total cost. The rode, swivels, chain, and shackles can add $500 to $700. For rode, we prefer double-braid or plait material; three-strand tends to unlay and hockle under high load. Follow the vendors advice on which rode material is best. Most vendors recommend rodes made of nylon, which is relatively elastic (helpful for absorbing shock), but Burke Marine recommends less-stretchy polyester for its Seabrake. Of those tested, Fiorentinos Shark was the easiest drogue to deploy, particularly in strong winds. It packed small, used a tail weight (typically a small mushroom anchor) in place of chain, and was the easiest to get into the water. Testers liked the compact and tangle-free construction, which appears to be designed to withstand anything. We did not field test a production version of the Shark, but our research, along with the data and video footage we reviewed and our extensive testing of a the scaled model suggest it behaves like drogues of similar design. Bottom line: Durability, stability, and appropriate drag levels earn the Shark a Recommended rating. The popular Galerider design shined in our tests, even as we pushed our speeds and loads higher. Based upon one-third-model testing, there seems to be no practical upper speed limit to its stable performance, and testers noted that it had considerably less tendency to surface at long rode lengths, even with no chain attached. It comes with its own shackle. This was the only drogue design tested that did not surface at 4 to 5 knots on 100 feet of rode. The drag numbers, whether near the surface or submerged, fluctuated far less than those of the other drogues. The designs many small openings seem to cancel out any oscillation. The only downside is the relatively low drag for its size, which means many boats will need a very large drogue. The metal mouth of the webbed basket will coil enough to allow for storage, but folding it requires a very firm hand to return it to the bag. Grip the drogue well when unpacking; it springs into shape with considerable force. Owners of older Galeriders should check the wire ring. There have been a few reports of wire ring failure. Fortunately, this isn’t crippling and is easily repaired, but it does cause increased yawing. Considering the long service history of the unit (more than 1,000 units over 20 years), durability has generally been very good. Recovery was easy, though its large mouth does like to snag rudders and transoms (a boat hook helps). Bottom line: The Galerider is the Best Choice drogue for steering and storm use. Jimmy Green Yacht DrogueA generic-looking cone, the Jimmy Green Marine Yacht Drogue 25 suffers from weaknesses common to this design group; it tends to yaw aggressively at speeds over 3 knots. When pulled from a wave, the occurrence is more sudden and complete than with other designs. We also have some concerns about its durability in a prolonged storm. On the other hand, it is much less expensive than other drogues and seems sturdy enough for some rough use. It also drains rapidly for easy retrieval. Bottom line: This drogue may be useful for emergency steering in moderate conditions with smaller boats, but is not recommended for sustained storms. Seabrake GP24LThe Seabrake GP24L, made by Burke Marine, has been in service for years on one of our test boats, a PDQ 32 catamaran. While weve found it useful for preventing a broach in steep breaking waves at inlets, weve not tested it in more severe conditions. When the bridle is shortened to reduce drag, it becomes a little less stable, though it never tangled or inverted in use. Retrieval ease met expectations for a larger drogue. Water drains quickly for recovery, and the design is snag-free coming on board. Bottom line: We Recommend the Seabrake for emergency steering on larger boats and for storm use on smaller boats. Delta Drogue 72The Delta Drogue was designed by a longtime player in this field, Para-Tech Engineering. Made of fabric and shaped like an equilateral triangle, the 72-inch Delta is dimensionally similar to other units in the test, such as the Seabrake GP24L. At very short scope, the Delta 72 occasionally had the bad habit of skipping out of the water when overloaded, but it always re-engaged before any effect was noticed. It behaved very well at normal scope. Since the drogue holds water, users must dump it during recovery before lifting it onboard. The elegantly simple design, which stows in a tiny bag, is functional, well-proven, and strong. Bottom line: The Delta 72 earned the Budget Buy pick for a real offshore drogue. Para Drogue SingleMade in the U.K., Ocean Safetys Para Drogue offered more drag than other speed-limiting drogues; however, we were only able to test this for a few hours in calm conditions. The Para Drogue seemed quite stable under a steady pull and was not prone to surfacing or yawing. Our impression was that it was more suited to speed limiting use in a strong storm or to assist with emergency steering on a larger yacht. Like all parachute drogues without tripping lines, recovery was cumbersome but not unreasonable. Bottom line: There is limited information on this device, and we did not spend enough time with it to offer a fair assessment. We would be interested in hearing first-hand reports from anyone who has used it (email [email protected] ) and will look for more opportunities to further evaluate it. Jordan Series DrogueAlthough we did not test a production-ready Jordan Series Drogue (JSD), our report in 2000 discussed the JSDs pros and cons, and there is plenty of data regarding its ability to create significant drag. The result of a U.S. Coast Guard research project led by former Massachusetts Institute of Technology professor Donald Jordan in 1987, the series drogue typically comprises 90 to 200 cones with 5-inch diameters evenly spaced along hundreds of feet of rode, with a weight at the rode end to hold the tail down. The brilliance of the design is that the failure of a single element, whether by mechanical failure or by being pulled out of the water, makes no difference. The pull is steady, whatever the conditions. The downsides are that the construction is bulky, the drogue is notoriously laborious to recover, and during a moderate gale, it will generate enough resistance to hold the boat nearly motionless, as with a sea anchor. For the JSD to perform as a drogue generally requires more wind and wave energy, as one would encounter in a severe storm. This design was developed for simplicity of construction, and many do-it-yourself series drogues have been built, although several sailmakers (including Ace Sailmakers) supply completed drogues. When compared to other drogues, the JSDs price seems high (see Value Guide), but the rode is included in the fabrication. Bottom line: When sized appropriately, the JSD drogue is well-engineered for storm survival. Recommended. To create a warp, testers used 200 feet of half-inch line plus 30 feet of 3/8-inch chain. The length we tested provided about 10 percent the drag resistance of appropriately sized drogues. If three to five times the length of chain and rope were deployed, the force would become noticeable, but it would still be less than the force generated by a conventional drogue. In tests, warps offered extremely easy deployment and recovery, and the drag was very steady. Bottom line: Warps can be useful for minor speed reduction in strong conditions, but not as a speed-limiting drogue, unless you deploy multiple warps. Weve seen reports of sailors using plastic milk crates as drogues and decided to try it out. The resulting drag was similar to the towed warp, but it was less stable. Bottom line: Probably not helpful. Testers were consistently satisfied with the drogues quality of construction, confirming the very low rates of construction failure for speed-limiting drogues. We would be happy sailing with any of them. We were pleased with how the data in our small-scale tests correlated with the full-scale testing. Drag consistently related to speed and size, roughly confirming the formula we used to estimate drag. Our small-scale testing was particularly useful in supplying higher speed data. The biggest surprises were the variability of the data and the surfacing behavior of drogues at short scope. The minor yawing of each drogue and wave action seemed to cause momentary fluctuations in the recorded loads. All of the drogues except the Galerider exhibited significant variation in the recorded loads during intervals as short as 5 seconds. This pulse-like tugging occurred even when we used 100 feet of rode. The Galerider, on the other hand, showed much less fluctuation. When towed at short scope, the same basic pattern continued, with drogues surfacing at about 4 to 5 knots and the loads becoming more variable. Again, the exception was the Galerider, which required more speed and less scope to cause excessive surfacing. While the Galerider is less efficient on a size basis (you need a big one), its stability and ease of recovery made it testers favorite. For economical stopping power, we like the Delta Drogue and the Seabrake. We will be following up this report with an article on using drogues for emergency steering. We will also take a closer look at recommendations for rigging and sizing drogues. We are particularly interested in input from sailors who have used drogues in gale conditions. You can send your reports to [email protected] . - Field Testing Drag, Behavior
Testers were always tethered to the boat, even in light weather. In heavy weather, two hands are required to manhandle drogues and the deck is moving; the tether saved us from going over many times. A bucket lashed to the stern rail was handy for handling chain rode without scratching gelcoat. - The Delta was a handful to recover, unless the water was dumped first.
- A Galerider 30 (left), Seabrake GP24L (center), and Delta Drogue 72 (right) await their turn for testing.
- For data collection, we used one-third scale drogue models: (from left to right) generic cone, Shark, Delta, Galerider, and Seabrake. All performed exactly as calculations predicted they would, based on full-scale drogues’ actual performance. The smaller size allowed testers to really flog them to the edge of the design envelope. All performed quite well in very tough conditions.
The above table lists drogues recommended by their manufacturers for boats that generally fit in the 30- to 45-foot range. This is an estimated size, and the broad range of boats in this categorystretching between a Catalina 30 to a William Garden Vagabond 47illustrates the importance of consulting manufacturers and researching other reports when matching a drogue size to a boat. PS tested five of the above drogues. The source of other data is noted in the table. Each drogue maker suggests a size based on the length or weight of the boat. Drogue loads at 7 knots (see PS Value Guide above) are about 70 percent of the working anchor benchmarks, illustrating the importance of strong attachment points on deck. - Delta Drogue
- Series Drogue
- Shark Drogue
- Circumnavigators Beth Leonard and Evans Starzinger test the Galerider sea drogue in Southern Ocean storms.
RELATED ARTICLES MORE FROM AUTHORAnother Look at Fitting JacklinesCollision Avoidance When ‘See and Avoid’ FailsWhen a Welcome Home Becomes a RescueDear sir I want to use sea drogues for pulling ships at a water stream . Whai i want to know is : at what speed will a 40 inch diameter sea drogue pull a 50 ton ship if the speed of water stream is 1 knot . This will help me to know how many sea drogues i have to use to make a 50 ton ship sail at the speed of 4 knots ( when the drogues pull the ship after them . LEAVE A REPLY Cancel replyLog in to leave a comment Latest VideosSailboat vs Fishing Boat – Rules of the RoadCatalina 445: What You Should Know | Boat ReviewHow to Wax and Polish Your BoatBeneteau 46.1: What You Should Know | Boat Tour- Privacy Policy
- Do Not Sell My Personal Information
- Online Account Activation
- Privacy Manager
Log in or Sign upYou are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly. You should upgrade or use an alternative browser . how to make a drogue or sea anchorDiscussion in ' Boat Design ' started by sigurd , Jun 27, 2006 . sigurd Pompuous PangolinI have some strong fabric and an old singer sewing machine, said to be capable of heavy fabrics. I want to make a couple different sized brakes. How should they be shaped? FAST FRED Senior MemberThe easiest is a couple of auto or truck tires towed astern with a VERY stout line. No fabrication , no cost. Works great . FAST FRED Like this? Doesn't seem to slow him down a lot I think. I am not sure whether a fabric sock, with "drawstring" closure at one end, and a 3 or more part bridle at the other, would collapse? It could have some pipe insulator foam along the upper front edge, and a weight at the bottom front edge. Couldn't that be pretty stable? (pic from http://www.trim.no/images/artikkel/standard/bergemiddels.jpg ) Attached Files:Bergemiddels.jpg. MarkC Senior MemberThe US Coast Guard has put forward a different approach. Trail from the rear a long line with many small 'chutes' sewn on. They have tested it too. Fairly damning of the big Parachute drogue. If I can remember the web-site? JPC Junior MemberTough Issue This is a tough one: there are a lot more opinions than experience out there. I will readily volunteer that I have an ear-bending volume of opinions, and I have done a substantial amount of offshore sailing, but I have NEVER used a drag device. -so, my comments are just theory. I think that people will agree with the comment that the best storm device will vary depending upon the characteristics of the vessel, the weather/sea conditions, and the crew. With that obvious declaration made, I can tell you where I've come out on trying to answer the same question: I go with the Jordan Series Drogue. You can make one yourself, or you can purchase one at: http://www.jordanseriesdrogue.com/ Here's some general drag device info: http://seriesdrogue.com/coastguardreport/droguereport.htm That babychute tail looks very neat! Can you explain to me how those little chutes are attached to the main rope so that I can make one? sorry, I didn't "have time" to wade through the whole of the links before I posted. Great links! I think I know how to construct it now. For continuity, here is the answer to my question: http://seriesdrogue.com/coastguardreport/figure17.htm Don Jordan answered me also immediately and gave more details. Glad that the answer was available. Since the load on any individual "pocket" will not be that great, the details of assembly should not be too critical and it's reasonable to take on the project yourself. That said, I know I'm too much of a procrastinator and the drogue would live, half-completed, on my living room floor for months - I'll have the guys in Annapolis make one for me! I'll be interested in your thoughts and experience. One of the questions that I haven't answered for myself is whether there's any meaningful value in rigging the drogue with a bridle - that is, whether a bridle-rigged series drogue would contribute meaningfully to maintaining the heading of the boat. I think that Linda Dashew discusses making a series drogue in "The Offshore Cruising Encyclopedia" or "Survive the Storm". There are also valuable references to the use of the series drogue and other storm devices in Allard Cole's "Heavy Weather Sailing", "Fastnet Force 10", and the several books on the '98 Sydney-Hobart Race, among others. Best regards, JPC bilbobaggins Junior MemberDrogues and sea-anchors It's VIP to differentiate between devices intended just to slow the boat down, while still continuing to sail, and devices intended to STOP the boat. The first group include 'towing warps', sometimes with tyres, anchors, conical drogues attached. This presents the stern to the following seas, which becomes problematic when the cockpit is regularly swamped by breaking seas. Catamarans with 'patio doors' are vulnerable to downflooding. Someone must remain at the helm, steering, hour after hour. The second group utilises a much larger 'drag-generating' device, which grips a weight of seawater greater than that of the boat, while the bows are presented to the seas. A very long, 'elastic' nylon rode is used, which absorbs shock-loading, and ensures the drag device remains embedded in the body of a sea, two removed from the boat. A bridle arrangement is effective on a multihull, while less so on a monomaran. The idea is that the boat is stopped/'parked up', facing the seas, while everyone is below sheltering and resting. Whatever system is chosen, it is essential that the gear used is well strong enough for the job, and is protected adequately from chafe. Loads imparted on the boat - and her fittings - are enormous. The accounts of successful deployments stress this, while some accounts of unsuccessful encounters admit that the gear used was too small/too weakened by UV/chafed through/not strong enough somewhere. There are lots of folk with strong opinions - and no experience - who haven't even studied the accounts of those who have serious and successful experience of survival storms using drag devices. Try reading this stuff... http://www.biggideas.com/sea-anchor/html/data.html and 'Heavy Weather Sailing' published by Adlard Coles. Controversial stuff for sure. I don't have any experience in more than 50kt, and we were sailing. One thing that tends to confuse my intuition a bit is that the water doesn't move a lot with respect to the ground, whereas the wind does. So eventually it does seem plausible that the boat will generally move to leeward with respect to the water, even with a huge sea anchor. Thus I would think that the bow should point downwind in order to have a steady yaw with the smallest drogue, thus lower loads. But as you point out some boats may not take this very well due to flooding of the cockpit etc. Jordan claims there has been no damage from using the aft-deployed series chutes. Here is a quote from paratech backing up the idea that bow-deployed devices need to be draggier, and why they are needed (at least on some boats). "Please Note: Although it is much easier to pull the stern of the boat into the seas(even with a smaller Sea-Anchor) we consider it unwise in heavy weather situations. Because 99% of present day boats are designed to take the seas on the bow, we likewise have designed our present day Sea-Anchors for use off the bow only. They are true offshore anchors and as such are not to be confused with speed-limiting drogues used off the stern." Another situation may be if you have a multihull where you can raise the appendages. Then the bows, being sharpest, would be the most effective "feather", and the whole problem of going backwards likely diminishes. I experience this effect even in the little fat europe dinghy - it hates to be towed straight forward because of the sharp bow - but towing it backwards tends to be stable. There is one thing I feel certain about in mooring, at sea or elsewhere, and that is the importance of stretch in the system, in other words to even out the loads over time. this does decrease the max loadings. The babychute tail looks like it can do this in an elegant way. I don't see any reason why one style of drogue should be limited to deployment from only one end of the boat. both styles could be sized to do either. Don't talk to _me_ about procrastination! Does anybody have an opinion on the size of drogue for a 20' cat with no mast? say 300-500 kg? like I said, don't try to out-procrastrinate the pros. JPC - Thanks for providing the links to the US Coast Guard's report on the series drogue. I had forgotten No seriously - they have it covered. It is all there.:idea: bilbo Junior MemberCaution I would urge caution on those who would extrapolate from the 'US Coastguard' so-called test report, to use on real boats and real seas. First, the report is dated 1987 and is written by a Mr Jordan - who has a vested commercial interest. Second, the report confuses the different roles of a 'drogue' ( slows the speed of drift, while vessel continues ) and a 'sea anchor' ( vessel is stopped ). Third, the large-diameter parachute sea anchor, used now by hundreds of cruising yachtsmen, is neither tested nor discussed. It is simpy ignored. Fourth, the 'experimental' basis for the report's conclusions is a computer simulation model, and some measurements related to a small model boat in sheltered conditions. Hardly capable of scaling-up to survival storm conditions i.r.o a cruising yacht. Fifth, no mention is made of the body of experience of the use of such devices which has built up over the decades, including that of the RNLI cox'ns who have used conical drogues in breaking seas, for all of the history of that service. N.B. The lifeboat crews use of drogues is restricted to speed- and broaching control, in the final approach to a harbour/bar where breaking seas are encountered. Elsewhere, the vessel's manoeuverability and bouyancy is sufficient. By all means carry and use a Jordan Series Drogue system, or a small-diameter drogue. But, be aware of the limitations. Caution I would urge caution on those who would extrapolate from the 'US Coastguard' so-called test report, for use on real boats and real seas. First, the report is dated 1987 and is written by a Mr Jordan - who has a vested commercial interest. Second, the report confuses the different roles of a 'drogue' ( slows the speed of drift, while vessel continues ) and a 'sea anchor' ( vessel is stopped ). Third, the large-diameter parachute sea anchor, used now by hundreds of cruising yachtsmen, is neither tested nor discussed. It is simpy ignored. Fourth, the 'experimental' basis for the report's conclusions is a computer simulation model, and some measurements related to a small model boat in sheltered conditions - hardly capable of scaling-up to survival storm conditions i.r.o a cruising yacht. Fifth, no mention is made of the body of experience of using such devices which has built up over the decades, including that of the RNLI cox'ns who have used conical drogues in breaking seas, for all of the history of that service. N.B. The lifeboat crews use of drogues is restricted to speed- and broaching control, in the final approach to a harbour/bar where breaking seas are encountered. Elsewhere, the vessel's manoeuverability and bouyancy is sufficient. By all means carry and use a Jordan Series Drogue system, or a small-diameter drogue. But, be aware of the limitations. These have been highlighted again recently by the published experiences of designer Richard Woods. A 'too small' drag device, set off the bows, fails to hold the bows directly up into the wind and seas. The result is that the bows fall off, the vessel drifting bodily downwind about beam-on - exactly what one is trying to avoid.... IMHO, one may set a drogue, or Jordan Series Drogue, off the stern and continue steering downwind at reduced speed ( seas will break into the cockpit ) OR set a large parachute sea-anchor off the bows and entirely stop the boat ( seas will break over the bows ). Either way, all the gear used needs to be well strong enough for the very substantial loads that will be encountered. Please read the report. The reason for the report was stated as: As part of this report it is important to consider the question of why drogues have not been developed and accepted as a standard item of emergency equipment up to the present time. The following reasons seem to be of the greatest significance. Breaking waves capsize is relatively rare, and many sailors survive storms by lying ahull or by running off. They do not perceive the need for more gear. There is no firm specification for a drogue. When a makeshift arrangement has been tried it often has not worked and in some instances has made the situation worse. Prudent sailors are aware that a drogue can impose high loads on the boat. Since they do not know the magnitude of the loads they are reluctant to take the risk. In a survival storm the crew is of ten tired and disorganized. If the drogue is difficult or dangerous to deploy they are unable to handle the job. The research program described in this report is intended to address these concerns and to provide the information needed to make a rational decision on emergency equipment for the prevention of breaking wave capsize. Click to expand... Chainplates for a Fiorentino shark drogueCalculation for Chainplate for Series DrogueSports cars on the sea surfaceSmaller Sea sledsThoughts on this hull design - what seas and speeds etc.?Welding a sealed vessel?draggers eastern seaboard60-seats passenger boats, want top speed of 50knots, any ideaFar far, away from the sea... Lays a little shipyard....Small 2 seat speed boat- No, create an account now.
- Yes, my password is:
- Forgot your password?
|
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
A drogue streamed astern can help when a boat is being towed in waves, preventing snatching loads on the tow line and stopping the towed boat overtaking the boat doing the towing. 7 drogues tested: how we did it. We borrowed a Contest 29, Mohraina, moored at Poole's East Dorset Sailing Club and owned by Dick Hanraads. We headed out of Poole ...
Recommendation—Drogues The Jordan Series Drogue is in a class by itself. Much more of a sea anchor than a true drogue, it fixes a boat end-on to the wind and waves with a resilient efficiency that wins praise from all quarters. Your boat has to be designed and built to survive seas stern-on, however, before the JSD becomes a good option.
Toby Hodges tries out a ParaAnchor sea anchor and a Jordan Series Drogue on a heavy weather sail training weekend in the English Channel. Drogues and sea anchors are designed to slow a boat or ...
A sea anchor is deployed off the bow and is used to keep a drifting boat's head to the wind and waves so that it may ride rough seas more comfortably. A drogue is deployed off the stern and is used to keep the boat straight while motoring down-sea. Also, by slowing the boat as it races down a wave face, it reduces the chance for broaching or ...
The trip line and floats go out first, remember to deploy sea anchors from the bow and drogues from the stern. Allow the trip line to drift out and clear. Toss the drift anchor in next, making sure to toss it into clear water. As the boat drifts away from the anchor, pay out about 50' of rode and snub the line with half a turn on the cleat ...
Fiorentino Para-Anchors. The Storm Drogue. A storm drogue is a device towed submerged from the stern to limit (but not stop) the boat's speed, and to keep the vessel's stern at a set angle to following seas. Conversely, a sea anchor is a device deployed from the bow to stop the boat's movement through the water, and to keep the boat's ...
Marine Sea Anchors & Drogues. A sea anchor can be deployed off the bow and is used to keep a boat's head to the wind, and waves so that it may ride rough seas more comfortably. A drogue is deployed off the stern and will keep you boat straight while motoring down-sea. Marine sea anchors from Defender can also serve as a stabilizer in a ...
The use of drogues is relatively well known as a steering device for sailboats in the event of a lost rudder, but they can have an equally important application to the modern power cruiser. Mariners have known for centuries that dragging something from the stern of the boat will slow it and keep its stern square to the waves.
Jordan Series Drogue is a safety device designed to prevent the capsize and damage of both monohull and multihull sailing yachts and other vessels operating in the open ocean, in the event of a "worst case" breaking wave strike, as well as improving the motion of the boat in storm waves and to reduce drift. The Jordan Series Drogue has been at ...
Surviving a Force 11 storm with a series drogue. Small cruising boats are not fast enough to sail away from bad weather. Tony Curphey shares how a series drogue was vital while sailing the Southern Ocean in a Nicholson 32. When the windvane steering can no longer cope with the seastate, it is time to deploy the drogue.
As wind increases, ease the drogue back from the boat. This increases drag (steering force), and keeps the drogues stable. In strong winds, we set the drogue was about 60 feet behind the boat. For best control, reef earlier than usual. Keep the traveler lower than normal on all courses. As true wind nears the beam, consider striking the main.
The bottom line is that while a JSD tail could be used as a steering drogue in an emergency, a purpose-built steering drogue is better. Darrell Nicholson. Practical Sailor has been independently testing and reporting on sailboats and sailing gear for more than 50 years. Supported entirely by subscribers, Practical Sailor accepts no advertising.
Skip Novak's view is clear: although drogues could be a lifesaver on small boats of, say, less than 50ft, he would feel nervous about deploying the gear on bigger, heavier vessels. For smaller ...
PBO wrote: "Jimmy Green, based in Beer in East Devon, make a number of sizes of drogue - this one was a Size 10, suitable for Mohraina's 29ft. It comprises a PVC cone. At low revs, it reduced our speed from 3.5 knots to 2 knots. exerting 28kg on the line. Flat out, it reduced the boat speed from 7 to 4.5 knots, exerting 100kg on the line.
Para-drogues are not difficult to rig up. For example a 9ft diameter sea anchor - or para-anchor - is required to hold a bow head to wind, whereas a 3ft diameter para-drogue, when deployed astern, is designed to slow a boat allowing directional stability downwind. The 3ft drogue simply does not have the power that the 9ft para-anchor does ...
A general rule of thumb is to use one drogue for every 10 feet of boat length. For example, a 40-foot boat would require a series of drogues with four drogues. A helpful rule for sea anchors is that the sea anchor diameter should be roughly 1/3rd the boat's length. For example, a 48-foot boat would require a sea anchor with a diameter of ...
Galerider Drogue. The drogue provides elastic, but high resistance to eliminate surfing, yawing, and pitchpoling tendencies. In the trough, it continues to provide low resistance for steering control and function as an emergency tiller:. Updated in 2021 with eye & eye needle roller thrust bearing swivel designed to rotate under any load.
Carolyn used webbing to sew a slowing drogue that can be towed astern. Cap'n Fatty Goodlander. Next I relieved the pressure on the port end of the dragging line with a rolling hitch and short length of line secured on board. I tied the bitter end of another anchor line to the first, then cast off the rolling hitch.
A series drogue utilizes smaller drag devices, such as cones, all of which are attached along a length of rode. Unitary drogues Most drogues are unitary drogues, and most unitary drogues are intended to reduce a boat's speed to a safe and manageable level while allowing for a fair amount of directional control by the helmsman.
The above table lists drogues recommended by their manufacturers for boats that generally fit in the 30- to 45-foot range. This is an estimated size, and the broad range of boats in this category—stretching between a Catalina 30 to a William Garden Vagabond 47—illustrates the importance of consulting manufacturers and researching other reports when matching a drogue size to a boat.
US Sailing Safety at Sea training is one of the best in the world. From online to hands on training. To learn more visit https://www.ussailing.org/education/...
Sean, Yeah, I don't get it either. My understanding is the Jordan type drogue is to nearly "stop" the boat while others (Gale Rider, Sea Break) are designed as "speed reduction" drogues meant to slow boats to a 3-6 knot speed. I spoke to a gentleman who felt he deployed his drogue too early which caused him to be pooped badly, which created a whole string of bad events.
The lifeboat crews use of drogues is restricted to speed- and broaching control, in the final approach to a harbour/bar where breaking seas are encountered. Elsewhere, the vessel's manoeuverability and bouyancy is sufficient. By all means carry and use a Jordan Series Drogue system, or a small-diameter drogue.